I test golden bead exc on PVE does same dmg without it. I test on PvP does same dmg without it. So GM your programming is messed up or why is it even in game? Will be waiting your reply
Indeed they have, you can not argue with that If we talk about this, the damage increases on critical hit only and also have critical deff. We also have yy & bs damage, that works in pve for e.g for mobs yy&bs. Blue color - Yin Resist and Yang dmg. Red color - Yang Resist and Yin dmg. Yellow color - Body Resist and Soul dmg. Violet color - Soul Resist and Body dmg. Usually yy&bs system damage works better with low players in KL map. If your basic damage is top up with top relics and the mobs are dark-blue, or blue, meaning disadvantageous to you, the higher damage will surpass the yy&bs and will have only little effect. YY&BS should be in harmony with clothes, ornaments, weapon, other relics and pills. The mobs have basic and yy&bs damage and deff, but we do not know the proportion so your build also should be balanced.
After intensive training to catch up from Acclaim time I can say that YY, BS is complicated, but that relic damage can help in East, West Temple and Kunlun, but not alone.